A Grilled cheese sandwich is classic comfort food, but it’s not always easy to make.
Most people think that grilled cheese can only be made on the stovetop, but this isn’t true! You can also make grilled cheese in the toaster oven.
Follow our simple guide on how to cook grilled cheese in the toaster oven for a quick, easy, and cheap meal.
Why Use A Toaster Oven For Grilled Cheese?
The best thing about cooking grilled cheese in the toaster oven is how much faster it is than making it on the stove.
While you can still follow all of the same steps for making grilled cheese that you would use on the stovetop, like melting cheese between two pieces of bread with butter, using a toaster oven will cut your cooking time in half.
Additionally, you can make grilled cheese for a lot more people in the toaster oven than you would be able to on the stovetop. You can easily cook four sandwiches at once in the toaster oven, while only making two at a time on the stovetop.
With all of these benefits, it’s easy to see why using a toaster oven to make grilled cheese sandwiches will always be our first choice.
It’s perfect for an easy office lunch, late-night snack, or whenever you’ve got a gooey melty cheese craving!
Oven Grilled Cheese Sandwich Ingredients
For this recipe, to make two sandwiches you will need:
- 4 slices of bread
- 2-4 American cheese slices
- 2 tablespoons butter, softened
That’s all you need to make this simple yet delicious combo.
How To Cook Grilled Cheese In A Toaster Oven
- Turn your toaster oven on and preheat it to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. You can use an indoor or outdoor toaster oven for this recipe.
- Butter both sides of your bread slices, and place them on the toaster oven cooking rack with the buttered side facing down.
- Place your cheese slices on top of each slice of bread you have placed on the baking sheet inside the toaster oven’s cooking rack. You can add more or less cheese based on how cheesy you prefer your grilled cheese.
- Place the baking sheet with the sandwiches in for between five and ten minutes, or until the cheese is melted and the toast is golden brown. Flip the sandwich halfway through cooking and butter the remaining bread slice.
- Once the sandwiches are done, remove the baking sheet from the toaster oven, cut the sandwiches in half if desired, and serve while hot! (Don’t forget to use oven mitts!)
With this easy recipe, you can enjoy a quick and delicious grilled cheese in the toaster oven every time.
You can also use different types of bread, like sourdough or multigrain for a more interesting flavor. Or try adding some vegetables, like tomato slices or avocado, before cooking your sandwich!
Assembling Your Oven Grilled Cheese Sandwich
You are now ready to assemble your grilled cheese sandwich, so follow the steps below.
For each sandwich that you want to make, take one slice of bread and place it on a plate or cutting board, buttered side down.
Place two slices of American cheese on top of the bread you have placed on your plate. You can add more or less cheese based on how cheesy you prefer your grilled cheese.
Place the second slice of bread, buttered side up, on top of one slice of American cheese to finish off your sandwich.
With this easy recipe, you can enjoy a quick and delicious grilled cheese in the toaster oven every time.
You can also use different types of bread, like sourdough or multigrain for a more interesting flavor. Or try adding some vegetables, like tomato slices or avocado, before cooking your sandwich!
What Cheese Is Best On A Grilled Cheese?
Grilled cheese has been enjoyed for centuries, and the options of cheeses you can use to make it are almost limitless.
While American cheese is always popular on grilled cheese sandwiches, there are a lot of other delicious alternatives as well.
Here are our top choices of different types of cheeses you can use in place of American when making grilled cheese sandwiches.
Swiss Cheese
Using this type of cheese will give your grilled cheese sandwich a nice nutty flavor that pairs well with bread. You can either use pre-sliced or shredded Swiss cheese in your sandwich.
Feta Cheese
If you are looking to add a little saltiness to your grilled cheese sandwich, feta is a great choice. Feta also pairs nicely with tomato slices, which you can add before or after cooking the sandwich.
Gorgonzola Cheese
This type of cheese will give your grilled cheese a powerful, slightly sweet flavor that goes well with a variety of slices of bread and vegetables.
Grated Parmesan Cheese
Adding grated Parmesan cheese to your grilled cheese sandwich is a great way to add flavor and also make the bread slightly crunchy.
Provolone Cheese
Provolone cheese is specifically designed for grilling, so it will melt perfectly in your sandwich. Provolone also works well with just about any other type of cheese you add to your sandwich and has a slightly spicy flavor that tastes great with tomatoes and peppers.
What Bread Is Best For Grilled Cheese?
Grilled cheese sandwiches can be made with a variety of different types of bread, from plain white bread to artisan loaves.
While most people enjoy their grilled cheeses on standard white bread slices, there are tons of other options you should try out as well! Avoid shredded cheese, as it will melt too quickly.
Here are some of our favorite choices for different types of bread that go great with grilled cheese sandwiches.
Sourdough Bread
Another option for your next grilled cheese sandwich is sourdough bread! This type of bread slice will give your sandwich a great tangy flavor that works well with just about any type of cheese you are using.
Whole Wheat Bread
Another variation of bread that works well in grilled cheese sandwiches is hearty multigrain bread! Whole wheat, multi-grain, or rye are all good choices for tasty grilled cheese sandwiches. Any of these bread slices give the sandwich uber crispy edges and way more flavor.
Ciabatta Bread
A soft and chewy type of Italian bread makes excellent grilled cheese sandwiches. Ciabatta is a great choice if you want to make your sandwich with fruit, vegetables, or meat.
Baguette Bread
A crispy baguette bread is another option for grilled cheese sandwiches! This type of bread slice works well when you are using a variety of vegetables or other ingredients in your sandwich.
As you can see, there are tons of delicious ways to combine different types of cheese with different types of slices of bread for endless possibilities when making grilled cheese sandwiches!
Tips For Perfect Grilled Cheese In The Toaster Oven
If you want to use more than one tray of the toaster oven at once, stagger the pieces on each tray so that one half is on one tray and the other half is on another. This will help prevent your sandwiches from sticking together during cooking.
You can always experiment with different slices of bread, cheeses, vegetables, or seasonings to make your favorite grilled cheese recipe.
Making grilled cheese in a toaster oven is faster and easier than making it on the stovetop, so you can enjoy this classic comfort food more often.
Grilled cheese sandwiches are a quick and inexpensive treat that will satisfy your craving for something cheesy any time of day!
Our Favorite Toaster For Grilled Cheese Sandwiches:
- Make 2 grilled cheese sandwiches in just minutes
- Two reusable toasting baskets
- Select your preferred doneness on the toasting dial
- Equipped with cancel, preheat, and defrost functions.
- The housing and handles stay cool to the touch for keeping hands safe.
- Storage is made easy and tidy with a cord wrap
- Remove the toasting baskets and drip tray for simple cleaning.
Grilled Cheese Nutrition
Grilled cheese is the perfect quick meal for any time of day. It can also be fairly nutritious if you use the right ingredients.
Protein: A grilled cheese has nine grams of protein, which is great for staying full longer.
Calories: With only 311 calories per sandwich, grilled cheese is a quick meal that won’t leave you feeling bloated or uncomfortable after eating it.
Fat: One grilled cheese has 11 grams of fat, but this comes from the healthy fats in the cheese itself and can help you feel more satisfied.
Carbohydrates: A grilled cheese has 30 grams of carbohydrates, with five grams of fiber to help balance out your blood sugar levels.
Sodium: With 517 milligrams of sodium, grilled cheese has a high amount of salt content that can cause health problems for people who eat too much.
What To Have With Your Grilled Cheese Sandwiches?
Our family has always loved a soup and sandwich lunch. Clam chowder, chicken noodle soup, and tomato soup are all delicious with a grilled cheese sandwich.
You can also easily grill some vegetables to have with your sandwich. Peppers, onions, mushrooms, and even eggplant taste great on top of melted cheese!
A glass of milk is the perfect companion for any grilled cheese sandwich.
Toaster Oven Grilled Cheese Sandwich FAQ:
How do you grill in a toaster oven?
You can’t grill in a toaster oven in the same way that you would grill in an outdoor barbecue. However, there are a few things that you can do to get close to the experience of grilling indoors.
One option is to preheat your toaster oven on the broil setting and then place the food directly on the top wire rack. Another option is to use an oven-safe skillet or tray and place it on the top wire rack.
Make sure that whatever method you choose, the food is not too crowded so that it has plenty of room to cook evenly.
How long does it take to toast a sandwich in a toaster oven?
It typically takes around 5-8 minutes to toast a sandwich in a toaster oven.
The time it takes to toast a sandwich in a toaster oven will vary depending on the size and thickness of the sandwich, as well as the wattage of your toaster oven.
Generally speaking, smaller and thinner sandwiches will take less time to toast than larger and thicker sandwiches. And higher wattage toaster ovens will toast sandwiches faster than lower wattage models.
Wrapping Up Your Crispy Oven Grilled Cheese Sandwich
So there you have it – a foolproof guide on how to make a perfectly toasted grilled cheese in your toaster oven. Just remember, the key is to layer the cheese properly and use a low heat setting so that the bread slice doesn’t burn.
And of course, don’t forget the butter! Enjoy this classic comfort food dish any time you want by following these simple steps. Do you have any favorite grilled cheese recipes?
Toaster Oven Grilled Cheese
Grilled Cheese sandwiches are a favorite among most people, and this recipe makes it easy to enjoy one in just minutes! The perfect sandwich for quick meals or snacks.
Ingredients
- 2 Slices of bread
- 1-2 Slices of American cheese
- 2 Tablespoons of butter, softened
Instructions
- 1. Turn your toaster oven on and preheat it to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. You can use an indoor or outdoor toaster oven for this recipe.
- 2. Butter both sides of your bread slices, and place them on the toaster oven tray with the buttered side facing down.
- 3. Place your slices of American cheese on top of each slice of bread you have placed in the toaster oven. You can add more or less cheese based on how cheesy you prefer your grilled cheese.
- 4. Place the tray with the sandwiches in for between five and ten minutes, or until the cheese is melted and toast is golden brown.
- 5. Once the sandwiches are done, remove them from the toaster oven, cut them in half if desired, and serve while hot!
Nutrition Information:
Yield: 1 Serving Size: 1Amount Per Serving: Calories: 311Total Fat: 11gCarbohydrates: 30gProtein: 9g
