You’ve just brought home a delicious pizza from your favorite pizzeria, but don’t know how to reheat it so it’s still as good as when it was first made.
You might be tempted to pop that pizza in the microwave for a few seconds, but you’ll end up with a soggy mess. The same goes for reheating pizza in the oven – it can be tricky to get the crust just right.
I’ve tried all the tricks for reheating pizza, and the best way to do it is in a toaster oven. It takes a little longer than the microwave or oven, but it’s worth it because your pizza will come out perfectly crispy every time.
How Do I Reheat Pizza In Toaster Oven?
Reheating pizza slices in a toaster oven is the perfect option if you do have a little free time or want crisp and crunchy crusts. You’ll have to wait a few minutes for the oven to heat and the pizza to heat up and the result will be a tasteful slice that’s almost as good as fresh Pizza.
Fortunately for those who need a little help heating frozen pizza, use the toaster oven preheat setting at 350 degrees Fahrenheit and then baking your pizza at 350 degrees for 10-15 minutes usually does the trick.
- Step 1: Preheat your toaster oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit.
- Step 2: Once the toaster oven is preheated place your pizza slices in the oven.
- Step 3: Let the pizza cook for 10-15 minutes. (The pizza is ready once the cheese gets melty)
- Step 4: Take your pizza out to cool down.
- Step 5: Enjoy your cheesy masterpiece!
Check out our favorite toaster oven designed specifically for reheating pizza!
How Do I Heat Pizza In The Microwave?
Many people complain about pizza making in the microwave having a chewy texture. The trick is adding water to your cup. It will therefore reduce the amount of energy the pizza absorbs meaning its heating takes longer and it won’t become squishy.
You can also reheat pizza slices in just four quick steps. This is usually how we use microwaves for warming up frozen/leftover pizza. It also makes it possible to reheat frozen pizzas. Just cool down the dough.
- Step 1: Place your leftover pizza and a small cup of water into the microwave.
- Step 2: Nuke the pizza on medium heat for 30-second intervals.
- Step 3: Your pizza should be warm and ready to eat in just a few minutes.
- Step 4: Take your pizza out to cool down and enjoy!
How Do I Heat Pizza In A Baking Pan?
Image From Anthony Falco
Anthony Falco ahead of Pizza Masters at Roberta’s of Brooklyn says the best method reheats pizza is the baking pan method. Several commentators say that cast iron skillets are superior but do not provide more control over them. Learn how to reheat a pizza recipe in a skillet.
The trick with this method is using droplets of water to help get the cheese to melt. You can place aluminum foil on the baking pan if you don’t want to clean up any mess afterward.
Doing it in five simple steps gives you the ready-prepared time to prepare a new pizza.
How Do I Heat Pizza In An Air Fryer?
This is the best way to recreate a fresh pizza without a toaster oven. Just lay out those leftover pizza slices on medium heat at 350 degrees Fahrenheit for between 7 and 10 minutes. It is just that the oil melts giving the crust a crispy crispness but it has a softness on the outside.
You can also reheat pre-cooked pizza in an air fryer by using the defrost setting. The total cooking time will depend on how crispy you like your pizza (normally 5-15 minutes).
Pre-heating the air fryer with empty trays before adding your food does result in more evenly cooked, crispier food without any added fat. This may be desirable for foods that are not already high in fat content. This method also works for our family’s favorite pizza rolls!
- Step 1: Set your air fryer to 350 and start preheating.
- Step 2: Once your air fryer is preheated place the pizza slices into the air fryer’s tray.
- Step 3: Spray a small amount of cooking spray over your pizza.
- Step 4: Let the pizza cook for around 10 minutes.
- Step 5: Enjoy your air-fried pizza!
Toaster Oven Vs Alternative Pizza Reheating Methods
In comparison to a greasy skillet grill, charcoal, or pizzeria stone, this is the only alternative. The one thing about a regular microwave oven that distinguishes it from toaster ovens is the size. The bigger the toaster oven the better the results.
The temperature limits guarantee quality pizza. In the skillet that maintains the crispiness and makes the crust feel crunchy. The only difference is cheese and pepperoni which don’t cook well when cooked in a conventional oven using a baking pan.
But when baking with a skillet it’s easy to reheat a pizza, as do ovens and microwaves. The standard toaster oven too is fast too and produces timely results.
Tips For Heating Frozen Pizza In A Toaster Oven
Don’t put your pizza in your toaster oven for too long it can cause a burn on the cheese and dehydrate the toppings. Remove food when it’s bubbling and browned to prevent excessive cooking. The hot mixture is kept hot over a period of 30 seconds until the desired consistency appears.
When cooking under a fire or oven use a different plate or rack for other foods because their time varies depending on the thickness.
How Do I Store Leftover Pizza Slices?
Properly stored pizzas retain their quality for 2 to 3 days in a refrigerator and up to 3 months in a freezer. While it is acceptable to put the cardboard box with the leftover pizza into the refrigerator but removing them would not be the perfect method.
The box and the free circulatory air accelerate the dehydration process and it will be stiff and hardened within some minutes. There are other strategies to save your leftover pizza to make it ready for reheating later in the day, such as a cardboard box and circulatory air to make it fresh and ready for storage and delivery.
Reheating Frozen Pizza FAQs:
What Is The Best Temperature To Reheat Pizza In Toaster Oven?
When placing frozen pizza slices on a fire-proof dish or pizza stone make sure they will be heated only before the cheese melts on top and browns them out. It generally is agreed that a toaster oven should be set at 350 degrees.
If you’re using aluminum foil, fold a piece of foil over the crust — it will prevent it from burning.
What Is The Best Way To Reheat Pizza?
The best way to reheat a pizza after being refrigerated overnight and then reheat pizza in the toaster oven at 350 degrees for 7-10 minutes.
The toaster oven has three advantages over an oven or microwave: It heats up faster, doesn’t require any preheating before cooking, and can be used as a second oven when there’s no more space in the main one.
In addition to reheating pizza, you’ll find that using a toaster oven also works for reheating leftovers or making quick dinners from raw ingredients.
How Do I Avoid Soggy Crust When Reheating Leftovers In A Microwave?
Don’t emulsify the pizza in the toaster oven before heating. This can cause condensation when cooked. Do not place aluminum foil in your toaster oven as it causes uneven temperature and an unpleasant texture to your baked goods.
Bake the pizza slices directly on the wire racks in the toaster oven which allows for circulation and heat distribution as well as avoids a soggy crust.
Can You Reheat Pizza On Parchment Paper?
Yes if it’s a quick reheat, the paper will keep the moisture in so you don’t have to worry about burning.
If you are cooking pizza slices for an event place them on parchment paper on a cookie sheet and bake at 350 degrees F for 10 minutes. If you put them straight on the stone crust will be crispy crust but with too much time or temperature, they can burn which ruins all your hard work!
Is It Safe To Eat Cold Pizza?
It can be safe to eat cold pizza, but it depends on how long the pizza was out of the fridge before you ate it. If there were less than 4 hours between when you put your pizza in the fridge and when you ate it, then yes—cold pizza is safe.
But if there were more than 4 hours between putting your pie in the cellar and eating it, then no—cold pizza isn’t safe to eat because bacteria can grow on dairy products like cheese at temperatures they’d never grow at if they’re heated up first.
What Toaster Oven Setting Is Best For Pizza?
You should set the toaster oven to 350F. The pizza must be placed on a wire rack that is one inch from the top of your toaster oven, and it must be removed after 7-10 minutes.
Pizza reheating tips include not using a microwave because microwaves can cause water droplets to leak out of the dough and cause soggy crusts. Never use convection or prepare mode settings because these modes cook for a shorter time so the crust gets dry quickly.
And never turn your toaster ovens up over 425 degrees Fahrenheit because this will make it hard for moisture to heat up inside of your pizza and could lead to pockets in cheese that turn into crispy cheese when you let it cool off again later.
Reheating pizza in a toaster oven is an easy and convenient way to enjoy your leftover slices. If you’ve tried it before, we’re sure you know that not all reheated pizza slices turn out well. But now with these tips from the experts at The Savvy Kitchen, there’s no need for anyone to have soggy or burnt leftovers ever again!
Check out our blog post on how to reheat pizza perfectly every time by following this simple guide of what not to do (and what should be avoided) and then try these methods next time you indulge in some tasty leftover pizza. We can’t wait for you to give them a try and let us know how they turned out!